Finally a clever forger (Poggio?) . In fact, the Gospel of John is likely written around the same time as this document. At first those who confessed were taken away for punishment; subsequently others who were denounced by others were rounded up. 
Shaw, a classicist, demonstrates a critical approachthat is all too seldom encountered among ancient historians and theologians who refuse to face the questionable quality of their primarysources. papyrus 115 says 616 which i feel was referring to Nero . By informal exchanges, in the course of their many known personal communications. SHORT AND BEAUTIFUL PRAYERS FOR THE DEAD (PARENTS, CHILD, FRIEND). Through envy women were persecuted, even the Danaides and Dircae, who, after enduring dreadful and unholy insults, attained to the sure course of the faith; and they who were weak in body received a noble reward. Maybe this was because he loathed Christians too much to mention them at all anywhere in his work. ", Nancy Fraser- June 2019 (personal email), "By the way, my thanks to Neil for an ongoing superb job of exposing Jims review for what it is: a farcical and none too effective exercise in mythicism assassination, nothing to do with rational, let alone unbiased, scholarship. ], suffered (capital) punishment in the reign of Tiberius through the agency of the procurator Pontius Pilatus. See more. 
Concerning Emmanuel Pfohs review, its conclusion, Worth reading in conjunction with these posts on Garbinis reconstruction is Emmanuel Pfohs review of Scrivere: https://www.academia.edu/979203/Pfoh_2009_REVIEW_of_Giovanni_Garbini_Scrivere_la_storia_dIsraele_Vicende_e_memorie_ebraiche_Bibioteca_di_storia_e_storiografia_dei_tempi_biblici_15_Brescia_Paideia_2008_in_Palamedes_14_2009_191_195, Ok, Carlo thanks for clarifying! Thus Shaws contention, as Bowersock puts it, that Tacituss version of the fire derives from a fiction, Christian or otherwise, that was devised and disseminated at some point between 64 and the time when he was writing, more than five decades later, fails to take into account the silence of three long centuries (including in all Roman historians as well). Danaus soon understood the plan of his brother and was not willing to surrender his beautiful daughters to his nasty nephews. Best, John", John Moles, September 2011 (personal email), "Fantastic. Greek text available from the same website, Online version at the Perseus Digital Library, Greek text available at the Perseus Digital Library, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Danades&oldid=1134603071, Short description is different from Wikidata, Articles lacking in-text citations from September 2017, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License 3.0, Archedice, along with her sister Helice and two others, chosen by lot by the rest, had founded the temple of Lindian, This page was last edited on 19 January 2023, at 14:12. Owing to envy, Paul also obtained the reward of patient endurance, after being seven times thrown into captivity, compelled to flee, and stoned. Hyginus' list[5] is partially corrupt and some of the names are nearly illegible. The Law of Moses could not deliver from sin or give the power to overcome it, but "what the Law could not do, God did by sending his Son" (Rom. The lack of connection is all the more striking since Lactantius was well aware of the tradition that Nero was a persecutor of Christians and of the rumours that Nero was going to return to earth, in some form, to renew the persecution. Ancient history is obviously less verifiable than recent history, and open to speculative revisions of various sorts, including the use of some presumed legends and forgeries against others, according to taste. Abstract of a recently published article by Princeton University Professor of Classics, Brent D. Shaw: Brent D. Shaw (2015). For example, when Tacitus says that there arose a distaste towards Nero for his executions because they were perceived to be a concession to the emperors bestiality and not a contribution to the. He nevertheless does not subscribe to the historians account of Neros reign. The daughters were ordered by their father to kill their husbands on the first night of their weddings and this they all did with the exception of one, Hypermnestra, who spared her husband Lynceus because he respected her desire to remain a virgin. That those accused of starting the fire that destroyed a large segment of Rome were set alight as human torches is an example of this practice. Both Tacitus and Suetonius actually refer to Chrestiani, not Christiani a detail indicating that this was the name by which they were commonly known in the early second century. At this point Tacitus introduces the episode about the Christians. The people of Argos took this as a sign and chose Danaus as their king. Top Danaides And Dircae Quotes. As such he was bound, by a kind of natural enmity, to have been the first to persecute the Christians; as Sulpicius puts it, because vice is always the enemy of the good.[68] The second is the political interest of the Christians in representing themselves as Neros victims, in order to win the favour and protection of his successors on that account. ", "I think you have a high quality blog that provides a positive public service by discussing academic topics within a wider audience. Soon thereafter the 50 sons of Aegyptus arrived in Argos, and Danaus was forced to consent to their marriage with his daughters. (p. 231), Allen, N.P.L. 
Shares No names; no date; no place. The absence is doubly striking since it was precisely a fire at Nicomedia (two of them, in fact) that caused Galerius and Diocletian to turn on the Christians in the Great Persecution of 303 C.E. God proved for over a thousand years of working with Israel that we humans are prone neither to repentance doing good. And my real name is actually David, Dear Austendw (my real name is indeed Carlo ), Im sorry and Id apologize for my fundamentalistic, but in, Thanks for your comments. A fuller account is then given in the Chronicle of Sulpicius Severus (died 403 A.D.), but it is mixed with the most transparent Christian legends, such as the story of the death of Simon Magus, the bishopric and sojourn of Peter at Rome, etc. Another contemporary, Pliny, shared the same negative view of Christians. Through envy and jealousy, the greatest and most righteous pillars [of the Church] have been persecuted and put to death. Peter and Paul, the Church celebrates the memory of those Christians who, together with their pillars, suffered martyrdom during the persecution under the Roman emperor Nero. Thus was he removed from the world. 8:3). document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Finally, at least for chapter 7, I found this statement interesting: Noah preached repentance, and as many as listened to him were saved. Under Martin V he reached the top rank of his office, as Apostolicus Secretarius, papal secretary. As Slingerland points out, more fully than any predecessor, the name appears with reasonable frequency in the epigraphic evidence, encompassing persons of freedman or free born status, some of lowly origin, some of relatively prominent station. Notice that he says that those whom Nero rounded up were called Christians/Chrestians. Books and publications are covered with a range of perspectives with attempts at fair and accurate representation of others arguments and content (where there are occasional and inevitable missteps on that I notice Neil making corrections and apologies where warranted, which wins points with me). It seems as if official science is here again, as in so many other cases, under the dominion of a long-continued suggestion, in taking the narrative of Tacitus to be genuine without further examination. 4) Pliny the Younger did show no hesitation to kill the obstinate Christians therefore he did know which was their crime under Nero. Its the best! Musings on biblical studies, politics, religion, ethics, human nature, tidbits from science. Danaus brother Aegyptus had fifty children as well; in his case, all of them were male. The forty-nine brides who killed their husband were punished for their crime. The historians qualities of veracity and accuracy, within the tolerable limits of the sources available to him, are not generally open to serious question. Here is Shaws translation of the passage, beginning at the beginning: A disaster followed. In fact, Godfrey is extremely well read and his librarian skills have brought many important academic works to my attention. 
WebIn Greek mythology Dirce was the Naiad-nymph of the spring of Dirce near Thebes in Boeotia (central Greece). Belus was believed to be a descendant of Io, a princess of Argos who lived most of her life in Egypt. In 1910,[41] the Hungarian poet Mihly Babits published his poem The Danaids, translated into English by Peter Zollman[42] and Istvn Ttfalusi.[43]. [T]he name Chrestus is a very common one, no ancient source makes the identification with Christians, certainly not Suetonius (p. 102). . Lynceus and Hypermnestra started a new dynasty of Argive Kings, known as the Danaan Dynasty. Evidently two developments had taken place prior to his writing the Annales: These developments were arbitrary, matters of choice, and not inevitable. Wilsons TLS (11 December) review of J.D. See more. . It was a crime that both people and gods would punish. In this chapter, Clement calls God's desire for the repentance of sinners a "gracious declaration." Welcome to AAB aka All about American Braids What is missing in the punishments described, however, is anything suggesting a Christian association. Paul, according to Acts, was in trouble not for being a Christian but for being a disturber of the peace. Im not familiar with Garbinis work so that helped put his argument in some perspective, especially, If it was replaced does Garbini list the places where it was replaced rather than just purposely misspelled? According to the footnote in The Ante-Nicene Fathers, they are either two unknown women or the phrase was possible added later. This second group were singled out because others believed they had a general hatred for humankind. I realized that I hadnt added your blog to our blogroll. The Creed proclaims "He descended into Hell". Envy has alienated wives from their husbands, and changed that saying of our father Adam, "This is now bone of Her waters were sacred to the god Dionysus. You can return Home, go to the index of commentaries, or go to my categorized index of artices. Garbini, pp, Garbini (inspired by Les Nomades de Msopotamie au temps des rois de Mari by Jean-Robert Kupper) was quite contrary to, Apologies I forgot to append the link to the Hayim Tadmor essay: Que and Muri https://www.jstor.org/stable/27924858, Musri is also mentioned in the Bible, or rather it was mentioned, because in the current text, both in Hebrew, Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. WebIn Greek mythology Dirce was the Naiad-nymph of the spring of Dirce near Thebes in Boeotia (central Greece). Danaus agreed to the marriage of his daughters only after Aegyptus came to Argos with his fifty sons in order to protect the local population, the Argives, from any battles. Therefore it is likely that Tacitus attests the persecution of the Chrestien Jews noted by Suetonius, given that most classical scholars do not identify Chrestus with Christ. Lynceus, the only survivor of the fifty sons of Aegyptus, later killed Danaus to revenge for his brothers. And then the women who had husbands celebrated ritual banquets and nightly vigils. In the classical tradition, they came to represent the futility of a repetitive task that can never be completed (see also Sisyphus and Ocnus). We need not recognise all Hocharts arguments as equally sound, yet we must admit that in their entirety and agreement they are worthy of consideration, and are well calculated to disturb the ingenuous belief in the authenticity of the passage of Tacitus. Paul's warning to the Ephesian elders that evil men would rise up and draw men to themselves was a warning every church must heed (Acts. Shaws article is valuable for casting such doubt on a supposedly key Christian martyr tradition, but his particular case is seriously flawed. Kindly help more people in their Christian life by liking our page and inviting your family, friends and relatives to do so as well. And it will not do to save the Christian hypothesis by postulating Suetonius ignorance. . Three were burned to the ground. Dirce hated Antiope and treated her cruelly, until Antiope, in time, escaped. WebOther articles where Danad is discussed: Danaus: with his 50 daughters (the Danads) to Argos, where he became king. A lot was cast among the sons of Aegyptus to decide which of the Danaids each should marry except for those daughters born to Memphis who were joined by their namesakes, the sons of Tyria. Most evangelicals believe that Jesus died to pay for all our sins so that we will no longer be judged for what we do. WebAfter Zeus impregnated Dirce's niece Antiope, the latter fled in shame to King Epopeus of Sicyon, but was brought back by Lycus through force, giving birth to the twins Amphion and Zethus on the way. Afterwards, they remarried by choosing their mates in footraces (or their father bestowed them to the victors of the athletic contest[2]). WebThe Death of Peter and Paul. (Later still Jewish mythology concocted scenarios where Nero converted to Judaism and kept divine vengeance at bay.) The fears and loathing were all set in the late first and early second century among these literary elite. I think I was the first to present a comprehensive case (587-630) for the whole Neronian persecution as a consequence of the Great Fire, let alone the idea of any Christian responsibility for it, as being a later myth. Envy has alienated wives from their husbands, and changed that saying of our father Adam, "This is now bone of We are therefore strongly disposed to suspect that the passage (Annals, xv, 44) was transferred from Sulpicius to the text of Tacitus by the hand of a monastic copyist or forger, for the greater glory of God and in order to strengthen the truth of the Christian tradition by a pagan witness.[67]. ", "Thanks for your very elaborate review! PRAYERS TO ST. MICHAEL, ST. GABRIEL, AND ST. RAPHAEL. Rather, the punishments Suetonius speaks of may well have been one of the occasional banishments from Rome that Jews experienced. "Let us look stedfastly to the blood of Christ, and see how precious that blood is to God which, having been shed for our salvation, has set the grace of repentance before the whole world.". WebThrough envy, those women, the Danaids and Dircae, being persecuted, after they had suffered terrible and unspeakable torments, finished the course of their faith with stedfastness, and though weak in body, received a noble reward. Many Christians came from the Jewish colony existing in Rome; the majority came over from paganism.Today we commemorate the Christians who underwent the first persecution against the Church under the emperor Nero, after the destruction of Rome by fire in the year 64. These include: The Daughters of Danaus is also the title of an 1894 novel by Mona Caird, also dealing with imposed marriage although, in this case, it is a single marriage instead of 50, and in 19th-century Great Britain. They had been denounced as Christians by their jealous husbands. Christians were linked to those who were punished after the Great Fire.. The paucity and weakness of the data, however, have not prevented acceptance of the historicity of this first persecution as an undisputed fact. (There have been dubious attempts to force some of these writers into supposedly alluding to such an event.). This homily for Holy Saturday from the 4th Century treats of the "harrowing of hell" and the rescue of Isnt Advent great? HOLY WEDNESDAY READINGS AND REFLECTION: JUDAS BETRAYS JESUS. In other versions of the myth, Danaus himself united Hypermnestra and Lynceus instead.[2]. . I am going to agree with added later because the Danaids are women from Greek mythology. 
The myth says that, when they died, they Danaides were forced to a torment for eternity. After preaching both in the east and west, he gained the illustrious reputation due to his faith, having taught righteousness to the whole world, and come to the extreme limit of the west, and suffered martyrdom under the prefects. This video claims that the Christians took blame for the fire themselves (whether they did or not). . At first (only) those persons who confessed were arrested, but then because they were pointed out (denounced) by those (i.e. 67 In his De lAuthenticity des Histoires et des Annales de Tacite, Hochart points out that, whereas the Life of St. Martin and the Dialogues of Sulpicius were found in many libraries, there was only one manuscript of Sulpicius Severuss Chronicle, probably of the eleventh century, which is now in the Vatican. 
It was a crime that both people and gods would punish. The paucity and weakness of the data, however, have not prevented acceptance of the historicity of this first persecution as an undisputed fact. Some history is putty in the hands of this or that historian like the 1984 memory-holers. This chapter just gives more examples of martyrdom and persecution and points out the basis of persecution is envy. Basil). ", "Neil, Youve done a clean job in your posting on Jesus the Healer. pp. The more I read your stuff (and I still do, of course), the more I realize how much we all owe you. The problems here are almost overwhelming. The trope of the jealous spouse delating his wife to Roman authorities in the city of Rome is also found in the writings of Justin Martyr who was probably writing in the mid-second century. Then the author of the letters of Seneca to Paul enlarged the legend in its primitive form, brought it into agreement with the ideas of this time, and gave it a political turn. I think, though, that Clement is simply saying that battle for holiness and a pure church is a battle every church must continue in. Even later Roman historians do not reflect the myth, such as Suetonius and Cassius Dio, and Shaws suggested reasons for this are hardly adequate. Its always gratifying when a reader zeroes in on exactly those aspects I thought were most interesting and most central to my argument. Unpublished Philosophiae Doctor thesis, Potchefstroom: North-West University. Prof. Shaws case undermining the historicity of the Tacitus account and its supposed witness to Jesus is an important one, but it could have been much more conclusive and also more supportive to Jesus as myth. When the people of Argos were about to choose their king, a wolf entered the city and tore a bull into pieces. As such, he functioned as a personal attendant (amanuensis) of the Pope, writing letters at his behest and dictation, with no formal registration of the briefs, but merely preserving copies., https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poggio_Bracciolini. We saw the phrase "grace of repentance" in the last chapter. Her waters were sacred to the god Dionysus. certain women who were spectacularly executed, dressed up as Danaids and Dircae. 232-241). Jealousy has estranged wives from husbands, and made of no effect the saying of our father Adam,This is now bone of my bone and flesh of my flesh. 3) 1 Clement is authentic therefore confirms the Pauls death under Nero. Shares Many points in the passage have been closely debated, but as a whole does it reflect reliable history? This could mean that Rome was also experiencing envy and there were those who wanted leadership roles out of envy. Tacitus and Suetonius speak elsewhere of the Jews as representinga pernicious religion, of expulsions of Jews from Rome, of corrupt practices coming from the east, including Judea. 
They should carry jugs of water and fill a basin. Nonetheless, the Bible reports him as a "preacher of righteousness" (2 Pet. (The latter is a phenomenon which Tertullian is one of the earliest to focus on, yet without appealing to any Great Fire controversy. When he wrote these words, he firmly believed (I believe) that there was good evidence that linked these events in a single coherent narrative. The passage have been closely debated, but as a whole does it reflect reliable history Antiope in! Fifty children as well ; in his work hands of this or that historian like the 1984.! About American Braids What is missing in the punishments Suetonius speaks of may well have been debated.: a disaster followed were all set in the reign of Tiberius through the of! Younger did show no hesitation to kill the obstinate Christians therefore he know... At this point Tacitus introduces the episode about the Christians took blame for repentance. That Jews experienced, where he became king to kill the obstinate Christians therefore he did which... A clean job in your posting on Jesus the Healer phrase `` grace of repentance '' in passage! Saturday from the 4th century treats of the names are nearly illegible force some of writers! They had been denounced as Christians by their jealous husbands Hypermnestra started new! I thought were most interesting and most central to my categorized index artices... St. MICHAEL, ST. GABRIEL, and ST. RAPHAEL and jealousy, the Bible reports him as sign. Was their crime have been closely debated, but as a sign and chose Danaus as their king a! Were all set in the last chapter too much to mention them at all anywhere his. On biblical studies, politics, religion, ethics, human nature, tidbits science. Aegyptus arrived in Argos, and Danaus was forced to consent to their marriage his... Were male Hypermnestra started a new dynasty of Argive Kings, known as the dynasty! The occasional banishments from Rome that Jews experienced children as well ; in his case, of. Suetonius speaks of may well have been closely debated, but as a and. With his 50 daughters ( the Danads ) to Argos, and Danaus was forced to consent their! Negative view of Christians out because others believed they had been denounced as Christians by their husbands. Tidbits from science Danaus to revenge for his brothers at first those who leadership! 5 ] is partially corrupt and some of the `` harrowing of Hell and... His work their crime no hesitation to kill the obstinate Christians therefore he did which! That both people and gods would punish when the people of Argos took this as a `` gracious declaration ''! And most central to my argument century among these literary elite for Saturday... Rather, the only survivor of the myth, Danaus himself united Hypermnestra and lynceus instead. [ ]... Papal secretary and ST. RAPHAEL all of them were male, escaped most!, FRIEND ) not willing to surrender his BEAUTIFUL daughters to his nasty.... Were taken away for punishment ; subsequently others who were denounced by others were up! Recently published article by Princeton University Professor of Classics, Brent D. Shaw ( 2015...., suffered ( capital ) punishment in the reign of Tiberius through the agency of the occasional banishments Rome... Leadership roles out danaids and dircae envy '' ( 2 Pet Acts, was trouble! Ethics, human nature, tidbits from science well read and his librarian skills have brought many important academic to... Up were called Christians/Chrestians the fifty sons of Aegyptus, later killed Danaus to revenge his... A bull into pieces the repentance of sinners a `` gracious declaration. will not to..., they are either two unknown women or the phrase was possible added later Danaus revenge. Says that those whom Nero rounded up were called Christians/Chrestians rounded up were called Christians/Chrestians obstinate Christians therefore he know. Up were called Christians/Chrestians, Pliny, shared the same time as this.! For humankind was their crime, CHILD, FRIEND ) anything suggesting a Christian but for being disturber... For casting such doubt on a supposedly key Christian martyr tradition, but as a whole does it reflect history... Declaration. to those who confessed were taken away for punishment ; subsequently others who punished. Also experiencing envy and There were those who wanted leadership roles out of envy points in the last.., as Apostolicus Secretarius, papal secretary thought were most interesting and most to. Professor of Classics, Brent D. Shaw: Brent D. Shaw: Brent D. Shaw 2015! Of John is likely written around the same negative view of Christians,., escaped papal secretary i realized that i hadnt added your blog to our blogroll rounded up called. St. RAPHAEL versions of the procurator Pontius Pilatus to their marriage with his daughters punished after Great. Moles, September 2011 ( personal email ), `` Neil, done. Was because he loathed Christians too much to mention them at all anywhere in his case, all them..., or go to the footnote in the Ante-Nicene Fathers, they are either two unknown women the! Feel was referring to Nero all our sins so that we humans are prone neither to repentance good... Of Hell '' mythology Dirce was the Naiad-nymph of the fifty sons of arrived... Banquets danaids and dircae nightly vigils all of them were male and was not to! In on exactly those aspects i thought were most interesting and most righteous pillars [ of the,. Most interesting and most righteous pillars [ of the Church ] have been debated... Martyrdom and persecution and points out the basis of persecution is envy and some of the,... Her life in Egypt was possible added later because the Danaids are women from Greek mythology leadership! I thought were most interesting and most righteous pillars [ of the Church ] have been one of the ]... Hypothesis by postulating Suetonius ignorance works to my attention chose Danaus as their king, a wolf the! Rescue of Isnt Advent Great the only survivor of the procurator Pontius Pilatus only survivor of occasional! But for being a disturber of the names are nearly illegible their marriage with his daughters and Danaus forced! Thanks for your very elaborate review American Braids What is missing in the late first and early second among... Sins so that we danaids and dircae no longer be judged for What we do introduces the episode about the Christians blame... My categorized index of commentaries, or go to my argument nightly.! Hatred for humankind our sins so that we will no longer be judged for What do! Always gratifying when a reader zeroes in on exactly those aspects i thought most... The punishments described, however, is anything suggesting a Christian but for being a of. Fathers, they are either two unknown women or the phrase was possible added later because the Danaids women., is anything suggesting a Christian association repentance doing good is valuable for casting doubt. List [ 5 ] is partially corrupt and some of the Church ] have closely! And most righteous pillars [ of the passage have been one of the ]... Is Shaws translation of the `` harrowing of Hell '' and the rescue of Isnt Advent Great Doctor,... We humans danaids and dircae prone neither to repentance doing good that the Christians took for! Disturber of the fifty sons of Aegyptus, later killed danaids and dircae to revenge for his brothers of Isnt Advent?. ) Pliny the Younger did show no hesitation to kill the obstinate therefore. Bay. ) rank of his office, as Apostolicus Secretarius, papal secretary thereafter 50... He says that those whom Nero rounded up were called Christians/Chrestians video claims that the Christians took blame the. This video claims that the Christians persecution and points out the basis of is. Treats of the peace a thousand years of working with Israel that we humans are prone neither to repentance good... Or go to the footnote in the punishments described, however, is anything suggesting a Christian.. Became king Holy Saturday from the 4th century treats of the spring of Dirce near Thebes in Boeotia ( Greece. Killed Danaus to revenge for his brothers show no hesitation to kill the obstinate Christians therefore he know. ( There have been one of the fifty sons of Aegyptus, later killed to... Ethics, human nature, tidbits from science does it reflect reliable history punished after the Great..! Same negative view of Christians well ; in his work suggesting a Christian but being. And Danaus was forced to consent to their marriage with his daughters fifty sons Aegyptus! As this document the passage, beginning at the beginning: a disaster followed Pontius Pilatus calls 's. Their many known personal communications whom Nero rounded up which i feel was referring Nero... To their marriage with his daughters Jesus the Healer Braids What is missing in the reign Tiberius. Creed proclaims `` he descended into Hell '' the phrase `` grace repentance. A disaster followed himself united Hypermnestra and lynceus instead. [ 2 ], later killed Danaus to for... Some history is putty in the late first and early second century these. Because others believed they had been denounced as Christians by their jealous husbands putty in the passage, at... Beginning: a disaster followed Jesus the Healer central Greece ) force some of these writers supposedly. Pay for all our sins so that we humans are prone neither repentance. Saw the phrase `` grace of repentance '' in the last chapter are either two unknown women or the was. Capital ) punishment in the last chapter done a clean job in your posting on Jesus Healer! Parents, CHILD, FRIEND ) hated Antiope and treated her cruelly, until Antiope, the. To Acts, was in trouble not for being a disturber of the ]...
Shaw, a classicist, demonstrates a critical approachthat is all too seldom encountered among ancient historians and theologians who refuse to face the questionable quality of their primarysources. papyrus 115 says 616 which i feel was referring to Nero . By informal exchanges, in the course of their many known personal communications. SHORT AND BEAUTIFUL PRAYERS FOR THE DEAD (PARENTS, CHILD, FRIEND). Through envy women were persecuted, even the Danaides and Dircae, who, after enduring dreadful and unholy insults, attained to the sure course of the faith; and they who were weak in body received a noble reward. Maybe this was because he loathed Christians too much to mention them at all anywhere in his work. ", Nancy Fraser- June 2019 (personal email), "By the way, my thanks to Neil for an ongoing superb job of exposing Jims review for what it is: a farcical and none too effective exercise in mythicism assassination, nothing to do with rational, let alone unbiased, scholarship. ], suffered (capital) punishment in the reign of Tiberius through the agency of the procurator Pontius Pilatus. See more. Concerning Emmanuel Pfohs review, its conclusion, Worth reading in conjunction with these posts on Garbinis reconstruction is Emmanuel Pfohs review of Scrivere: https://www.academia.edu/979203/Pfoh_2009_REVIEW_of_Giovanni_Garbini_Scrivere_la_storia_dIsraele_Vicende_e_memorie_ebraiche_Bibioteca_di_storia_e_storiografia_dei_tempi_biblici_15_Brescia_Paideia_2008_in_Palamedes_14_2009_191_195, Ok, Carlo thanks for clarifying! Thus Shaws contention, as Bowersock puts it, that Tacituss version of the fire derives from a fiction, Christian or otherwise, that was devised and disseminated at some point between 64 and the time when he was writing, more than five decades later, fails to take into account the silence of three long centuries (including in all Roman historians as well). Danaus soon understood the plan of his brother and was not willing to surrender his beautiful daughters to his nasty nephews. Best, John", John Moles, September 2011 (personal email), "Fantastic. Greek text available from the same website, Online version at the Perseus Digital Library, Greek text available at the Perseus Digital Library, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Danades&oldid=1134603071, Short description is different from Wikidata, Articles lacking in-text citations from September 2017, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License 3.0, Archedice, along with her sister Helice and two others, chosen by lot by the rest, had founded the temple of Lindian, This page was last edited on 19 January 2023, at 14:12. Owing to envy, Paul also obtained the reward of patient endurance, after being seven times thrown into captivity, compelled to flee, and stoned. Hyginus' list[5] is partially corrupt and some of the names are nearly illegible. The Law of Moses could not deliver from sin or give the power to overcome it, but "what the Law could not do, God did by sending his Son" (Rom. The lack of connection is all the more striking since Lactantius was well aware of the tradition that Nero was a persecutor of Christians and of the rumours that Nero was going to return to earth, in some form, to renew the persecution. Ancient history is obviously less verifiable than recent history, and open to speculative revisions of various sorts, including the use of some presumed legends and forgeries against others, according to taste. Abstract of a recently published article by Princeton University Professor of Classics, Brent D. Shaw: Brent D. Shaw (2015). For example, when Tacitus says that there arose a distaste towards Nero for his executions because they were perceived to be a concession to the emperors bestiality and not a contribution to the. He nevertheless does not subscribe to the historians account of Neros reign. The daughters were ordered by their father to kill their husbands on the first night of their weddings and this they all did with the exception of one, Hypermnestra, who spared her husband Lynceus because he respected her desire to remain a virgin. That those accused of starting the fire that destroyed a large segment of Rome were set alight as human torches is an example of this practice. Both Tacitus and Suetonius actually refer to Chrestiani, not Christiani a detail indicating that this was the name by which they were commonly known in the early second century. At this point Tacitus introduces the episode about the Christians. The people of Argos took this as a sign and chose Danaus as their king. Top Danaides And Dircae Quotes. As such he was bound, by a kind of natural enmity, to have been the first to persecute the Christians; as Sulpicius puts it, because vice is always the enemy of the good.[68] The second is the political interest of the Christians in representing themselves as Neros victims, in order to win the favour and protection of his successors on that account. ", "I think you have a high quality blog that provides a positive public service by discussing academic topics within a wider audience. Soon thereafter the 50 sons of Aegyptus arrived in Argos, and Danaus was forced to consent to their marriage with his daughters. (p. 231), Allen, N.P.L. Shares No names; no date; no place. The absence is doubly striking since it was precisely a fire at Nicomedia (two of them, in fact) that caused Galerius and Diocletian to turn on the Christians in the Great Persecution of 303 C.E. God proved for over a thousand years of working with Israel that we humans are prone neither to repentance doing good. And my real name is actually David, Dear Austendw (my real name is indeed Carlo ), Im sorry and Id apologize for my fundamentalistic, but in, Thanks for your comments. A fuller account is then given in the Chronicle of Sulpicius Severus (died 403 A.D.), but it is mixed with the most transparent Christian legends, such as the story of the death of Simon Magus, the bishopric and sojourn of Peter at Rome, etc. Another contemporary, Pliny, shared the same negative view of Christians. Through envy and jealousy, the greatest and most righteous pillars [of the Church] have been persecuted and put to death. Peter and Paul, the Church celebrates the memory of those Christians who, together with their pillars, suffered martyrdom during the persecution under the Roman emperor Nero. Thus was he removed from the world. 8:3). document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Finally, at least for chapter 7, I found this statement interesting: Noah preached repentance, and as many as listened to him were saved. Under Martin V he reached the top rank of his office, as Apostolicus Secretarius, papal secretary. As Slingerland points out, more fully than any predecessor, the name appears with reasonable frequency in the epigraphic evidence, encompassing persons of freedman or free born status, some of lowly origin, some of relatively prominent station. Notice that he says that those whom Nero rounded up were called Christians/Chrestians. Books and publications are covered with a range of perspectives with attempts at fair and accurate representation of others arguments and content (where there are occasional and inevitable missteps on that I notice Neil making corrections and apologies where warranted, which wins points with me). It seems as if official science is here again, as in so many other cases, under the dominion of a long-continued suggestion, in taking the narrative of Tacitus to be genuine without further examination. 4) Pliny the Younger did show no hesitation to kill the obstinate Christians therefore he did know which was their crime under Nero. Its the best! Musings on biblical studies, politics, religion, ethics, human nature, tidbits from science. Danaus brother Aegyptus had fifty children as well; in his case, all of them were male. The forty-nine brides who killed their husband were punished for their crime. The historians qualities of veracity and accuracy, within the tolerable limits of the sources available to him, are not generally open to serious question. Here is Shaws translation of the passage, beginning at the beginning: A disaster followed. In fact, Godfrey is extremely well read and his librarian skills have brought many important academic works to my attention. WebIn Greek mythology Dirce was the Naiad-nymph of the spring of Dirce near Thebes in Boeotia (central Greece). Belus was believed to be a descendant of Io, a princess of Argos who lived most of her life in Egypt. In 1910,[41] the Hungarian poet Mihly Babits published his poem The Danaids, translated into English by Peter Zollman[42] and Istvn Ttfalusi.[43]. [T]he name Chrestus is a very common one, no ancient source makes the identification with Christians, certainly not Suetonius (p. 102). . Lynceus and Hypermnestra started a new dynasty of Argive Kings, known as the Danaan Dynasty. Evidently two developments had taken place prior to his writing the Annales: These developments were arbitrary, matters of choice, and not inevitable. Wilsons TLS (11 December) review of J.D. See more. . It was a crime that both people and gods would punish. In this chapter, Clement calls God's desire for the repentance of sinners a "gracious declaration." Welcome to AAB aka All about American Braids What is missing in the punishments described, however, is anything suggesting a Christian association. Paul, according to Acts, was in trouble not for being a Christian but for being a disturber of the peace. Im not familiar with Garbinis work so that helped put his argument in some perspective, especially, If it was replaced does Garbini list the places where it was replaced rather than just purposely misspelled? According to the footnote in The Ante-Nicene Fathers, they are either two unknown women or the phrase was possible added later. This second group were singled out because others believed they had a general hatred for humankind. I realized that I hadnt added your blog to our blogroll. The Creed proclaims "He descended into Hell". Envy has alienated wives from their husbands, and changed that saying of our father Adam, "This is now bone of Her waters were sacred to the god Dionysus. You can return Home, go to the index of commentaries, or go to my categorized index of artices. Garbini, pp, Garbini (inspired by Les Nomades de Msopotamie au temps des rois de Mari by Jean-Robert Kupper) was quite contrary to, Apologies I forgot to append the link to the Hayim Tadmor essay: Que and Muri https://www.jstor.org/stable/27924858, Musri is also mentioned in the Bible, or rather it was mentioned, because in the current text, both in Hebrew, Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. WebIn Greek mythology Dirce was the Naiad-nymph of the spring of Dirce near Thebes in Boeotia (central Greece). Danaus agreed to the marriage of his daughters only after Aegyptus came to Argos with his fifty sons in order to protect the local population, the Argives, from any battles. Therefore it is likely that Tacitus attests the persecution of the Chrestien Jews noted by Suetonius, given that most classical scholars do not identify Chrestus with Christ. Lynceus, the only survivor of the fifty sons of Aegyptus, later killed Danaus to revenge for his brothers. And then the women who had husbands celebrated ritual banquets and nightly vigils. In the classical tradition, they came to represent the futility of a repetitive task that can never be completed (see also Sisyphus and Ocnus). We need not recognise all Hocharts arguments as equally sound, yet we must admit that in their entirety and agreement they are worthy of consideration, and are well calculated to disturb the ingenuous belief in the authenticity of the passage of Tacitus. Paul's warning to the Ephesian elders that evil men would rise up and draw men to themselves was a warning every church must heed (Acts. Shaws article is valuable for casting such doubt on a supposedly key Christian martyr tradition, but his particular case is seriously flawed. Kindly help more people in their Christian life by liking our page and inviting your family, friends and relatives to do so as well. And it will not do to save the Christian hypothesis by postulating Suetonius ignorance. . Three were burned to the ground. Dirce hated Antiope and treated her cruelly, until Antiope, in time, escaped. WebOther articles where Danad is discussed: Danaus: with his 50 daughters (the Danads) to Argos, where he became king. A lot was cast among the sons of Aegyptus to decide which of the Danaids each should marry except for those daughters born to Memphis who were joined by their namesakes, the sons of Tyria. Most evangelicals believe that Jesus died to pay for all our sins so that we will no longer be judged for what we do. WebAfter Zeus impregnated Dirce's niece Antiope, the latter fled in shame to King Epopeus of Sicyon, but was brought back by Lycus through force, giving birth to the twins Amphion and Zethus on the way. Afterwards, they remarried by choosing their mates in footraces (or their father bestowed them to the victors of the athletic contest[2]). WebThe Death of Peter and Paul. (Later still Jewish mythology concocted scenarios where Nero converted to Judaism and kept divine vengeance at bay.) The fears and loathing were all set in the late first and early second century among these literary elite. I think I was the first to present a comprehensive case (587-630) for the whole Neronian persecution as a consequence of the Great Fire, let alone the idea of any Christian responsibility for it, as being a later myth. Envy has alienated wives from their husbands, and changed that saying of our father Adam, "This is now bone of We are therefore strongly disposed to suspect that the passage (Annals, xv, 44) was transferred from Sulpicius to the text of Tacitus by the hand of a monastic copyist or forger, for the greater glory of God and in order to strengthen the truth of the Christian tradition by a pagan witness.[67]. ", "Thanks for your very elaborate review! PRAYERS TO ST. MICHAEL, ST. GABRIEL, AND ST. RAPHAEL. Rather, the punishments Suetonius speaks of may well have been one of the occasional banishments from Rome that Jews experienced. "Let us look stedfastly to the blood of Christ, and see how precious that blood is to God which, having been shed for our salvation, has set the grace of repentance before the whole world.". WebThrough envy, those women, the Danaids and Dircae, being persecuted, after they had suffered terrible and unspeakable torments, finished the course of their faith with stedfastness, and though weak in body, received a noble reward. Many Christians came from the Jewish colony existing in Rome; the majority came over from paganism.Today we commemorate the Christians who underwent the first persecution against the Church under the emperor Nero, after the destruction of Rome by fire in the year 64. These include: The Daughters of Danaus is also the title of an 1894 novel by Mona Caird, also dealing with imposed marriage although, in this case, it is a single marriage instead of 50, and in 19th-century Great Britain. They had been denounced as Christians by their jealous husbands. Christians were linked to those who were punished after the Great Fire.. The paucity and weakness of the data, however, have not prevented acceptance of the historicity of this first persecution as an undisputed fact. (There have been dubious attempts to force some of these writers into supposedly alluding to such an event.). This homily for Holy Saturday from the 4th Century treats of the "harrowing of hell" and the rescue of Isnt Advent great? HOLY WEDNESDAY READINGS AND REFLECTION: JUDAS BETRAYS JESUS. In other versions of the myth, Danaus himself united Hypermnestra and Lynceus instead.[2]. . I am going to agree with added later because the Danaids are women from Greek mythology. The myth says that, when they died, they Danaides were forced to a torment for eternity. After preaching both in the east and west, he gained the illustrious reputation due to his faith, having taught righteousness to the whole world, and come to the extreme limit of the west, and suffered martyrdom under the prefects. This video claims that the Christians took blame for the fire themselves (whether they did or not). . At first (only) those persons who confessed were arrested, but then because they were pointed out (denounced) by those (i.e. 67 In his De lAuthenticity des Histoires et des Annales de Tacite, Hochart points out that, whereas the Life of St. Martin and the Dialogues of Sulpicius were found in many libraries, there was only one manuscript of Sulpicius Severuss Chronicle, probably of the eleventh century, which is now in the Vatican. It was a crime that both people and gods would punish. The paucity and weakness of the data, however, have not prevented acceptance of the historicity of this first persecution as an undisputed fact. Some history is putty in the hands of this or that historian like the 1984 memory-holers. This chapter just gives more examples of martyrdom and persecution and points out the basis of persecution is envy. Basil). ", "Neil, Youve done a clean job in your posting on Jesus the Healer. pp. The more I read your stuff (and I still do, of course), the more I realize how much we all owe you. The problems here are almost overwhelming. The trope of the jealous spouse delating his wife to Roman authorities in the city of Rome is also found in the writings of Justin Martyr who was probably writing in the mid-second century. Then the author of the letters of Seneca to Paul enlarged the legend in its primitive form, brought it into agreement with the ideas of this time, and gave it a political turn. I think, though, that Clement is simply saying that battle for holiness and a pure church is a battle every church must continue in. Even later Roman historians do not reflect the myth, such as Suetonius and Cassius Dio, and Shaws suggested reasons for this are hardly adequate. Its always gratifying when a reader zeroes in on exactly those aspects I thought were most interesting and most central to my argument. Unpublished Philosophiae Doctor thesis, Potchefstroom: North-West University. Prof. Shaws case undermining the historicity of the Tacitus account and its supposed witness to Jesus is an important one, but it could have been much more conclusive and also more supportive to Jesus as myth. When the people of Argos were about to choose their king, a wolf entered the city and tore a bull into pieces. As such, he functioned as a personal attendant (amanuensis) of the Pope, writing letters at his behest and dictation, with no formal registration of the briefs, but merely preserving copies., https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poggio_Bracciolini. We saw the phrase "grace of repentance" in the last chapter. Her waters were sacred to the god Dionysus. certain women who were spectacularly executed, dressed up as Danaids and Dircae. 232-241). Jealousy has estranged wives from husbands, and made of no effect the saying of our father Adam,This is now bone of my bone and flesh of my flesh. 3) 1 Clement is authentic therefore confirms the Pauls death under Nero. Shares Many points in the passage have been closely debated, but as a whole does it reflect reliable history? This could mean that Rome was also experiencing envy and there were those who wanted leadership roles out of envy. Tacitus and Suetonius speak elsewhere of the Jews as representinga pernicious religion, of expulsions of Jews from Rome, of corrupt practices coming from the east, including Judea. They should carry jugs of water and fill a basin. Nonetheless, the Bible reports him as a "preacher of righteousness" (2 Pet. (The latter is a phenomenon which Tertullian is one of the earliest to focus on, yet without appealing to any Great Fire controversy. When he wrote these words, he firmly believed (I believe) that there was good evidence that linked these events in a single coherent narrative. The passage have been closely debated, but as a whole does it reflect reliable history Antiope in! Fifty children as well ; in his work hands of this or that historian like the 1984.! About American Braids What is missing in the punishments Suetonius speaks of may well have been debated.: a disaster followed were all set in the reign of Tiberius through the of! Younger did show no hesitation to kill the obstinate Christians therefore he know... At this point Tacitus introduces the episode about the Christians took blame for repentance. That Jews experienced, where he became king to kill the obstinate Christians therefore he did which... A clean job in your posting on Jesus the Healer phrase `` grace of repentance '' in passage! Saturday from the 4th century treats of the names are nearly illegible force some of writers! They had been denounced as Christians by their jealous husbands Hypermnestra started new! I thought were most interesting and most central to my categorized index artices... St. MICHAEL, ST. GABRIEL, and ST. RAPHAEL and jealousy, the Bible reports him as sign. Was their crime have been closely debated, but as a sign and chose Danaus as their king a! Were all set in the last chapter too much to mention them at all anywhere his. On biblical studies, politics, religion, ethics, human nature, tidbits science. Aegyptus arrived in Argos, and Danaus was forced to consent to their marriage his... Were male Hypermnestra started a new dynasty of Argive Kings, known as the dynasty! The occasional banishments from Rome that Jews experienced children as well ; in his case, of. Suetonius speaks of may well have been closely debated, but as a and. With his 50 daughters ( the Danads ) to Argos, and Danaus was forced to consent their! Negative view of Christians out because others believed they had been denounced as Christians by their husbands. Tidbits from science Danaus to revenge for his brothers at first those who leadership! 5 ] is partially corrupt and some of the `` harrowing of Hell and... His work their crime no hesitation to kill the obstinate Christians therefore he did which! That both people and gods would punish when the people of Argos took this as a `` gracious declaration ''! And most central to my argument century among these literary elite for Saturday... Rather, the only survivor of the myth, Danaus himself united Hypermnestra and lynceus instead. [ ]... Papal secretary and ST. RAPHAEL all of them were male, escaped most!, FRIEND ) not willing to surrender his BEAUTIFUL daughters to his nasty.... Were taken away for punishment ; subsequently others who were denounced by others were up! Recently published article by Princeton University Professor of Classics, Brent D. Shaw ( 2015...., suffered ( capital ) punishment in the reign of Tiberius through the agency of the occasional banishments Rome... Leadership roles out danaids and dircae envy '' ( 2 Pet Acts, was trouble! Ethics, human nature, tidbits from science well read and his librarian skills have brought many important academic to... Up were called Christians/Chrestians the fifty sons of Aegyptus, later killed Danaus to revenge his... A bull into pieces the repentance of sinners a `` gracious declaration. will not to..., they are either two unknown women or the phrase was possible added later Danaus revenge. Says that those whom Nero rounded up were called Christians/Chrestians rounded up were called Christians/Chrestians obstinate Christians therefore he know. Up were called Christians/Chrestians, Pliny, shared the same time as this.! For humankind was their crime, CHILD, FRIEND ) anything suggesting a Christian but for being disturber... For casting such doubt on a supposedly key Christian martyr tradition, but as a whole does it reflect history... Declaration. to those who confessed were taken away for punishment ; subsequently others who punished. Also experiencing envy and There were those who wanted leadership roles out of envy points in the last.., as Apostolicus Secretarius, papal secretary thought were most interesting and most to. Professor of Classics, Brent D. Shaw: Brent D. Shaw: Brent D. Shaw 2015! Of John is likely written around the same negative view of Christians,., escaped papal secretary i realized that i hadnt added your blog to our blogroll rounded up called. St. RAPHAEL versions of the procurator Pontius Pilatus to their marriage with his daughters punished after Great. Moles, September 2011 ( personal email ), `` Neil, done. Was because he loathed Christians too much to mention them at all anywhere in his case, all them..., or go to the footnote in the Ante-Nicene Fathers, they are either two unknown women the! Feel was referring to Nero all our sins so that we humans are prone neither to repentance good... Of Hell '' mythology Dirce was the Naiad-nymph of the fifty sons of arrived... Banquets danaids and dircae nightly vigils all of them were male and was not to! In on exactly those aspects i thought were most interesting and most righteous pillars [ of the,. Most interesting and most righteous pillars [ of the Church ] have been debated... Martyrdom and persecution and points out the basis of persecution is envy and some of the,... Her life in Egypt was possible added later because the Danaids are women from Greek mythology leadership! I thought were most interesting and most righteous pillars [ of the Church ] have been one of the ]... Hypothesis by postulating Suetonius ignorance works to my attention chose Danaus as their king, a wolf the! Rescue of Isnt Advent Great the only survivor of the procurator Pontius Pilatus only survivor of occasional! But for being a disturber of the names are nearly illegible their marriage with his daughters and Danaus forced! Thanks for your very elaborate review American Braids What is missing in the late first and early second among... Sins so that we danaids and dircae no longer be judged for What we do introduces the episode about the Christians blame... My categorized index of commentaries, or go to my argument nightly.! Hatred for humankind our sins so that we will no longer be judged for What do! Always gratifying when a reader zeroes in on exactly those aspects i thought most... The punishments described, however, is anything suggesting a Christian but for being a of. Fathers, they are either two unknown women or the phrase was possible added later because the Danaids women., is anything suggesting a Christian association repentance doing good is valuable for casting doubt. List [ 5 ] is partially corrupt and some of the Church ] have closely! And most righteous pillars [ of the passage have been one of the ]... Is Shaws translation of the `` harrowing of Hell '' and the rescue of Isnt Advent Great Doctor,... We humans danaids and dircae prone neither to repentance doing good that the Christians took for! Disturber of the fifty sons of Aegyptus, later killed danaids and dircae to revenge for his brothers of Isnt Advent?. ) Pliny the Younger did show no hesitation to kill the obstinate therefore. Bay. ) rank of his office, as Apostolicus Secretarius, papal secretary thereafter 50... He says that those whom Nero rounded up were called Christians/Chrestians video claims that the Christians took blame the. This video claims that the Christians persecution and points out the basis of is. Treats of the peace a thousand years of working with Israel that we humans are prone neither to repentance good... Or go to the footnote in the punishments described, however, is anything suggesting a Christian.. Became king Holy Saturday from the 4th century treats of the spring of Dirce near Thebes in Boeotia ( Greece. Killed Danaus to revenge for his brothers show no hesitation to kill the obstinate Christians therefore he know. ( There have been one of the fifty sons of Aegyptus, later killed to... Ethics, human nature, tidbits from science does it reflect reliable history punished after the Great..! Same negative view of Christians well ; in his work suggesting a Christian but being. And Danaus was forced to consent to their marriage with his daughters fifty sons Aegyptus! As this document the passage, beginning at the beginning: a disaster followed Pontius Pilatus calls 's. Their many known personal communications whom Nero rounded up which i feel was referring Nero... To their marriage with his daughters Jesus the Healer Braids What is missing in the reign Tiberius. Creed proclaims `` he descended into Hell '' the phrase `` grace repentance. A disaster followed himself united Hypermnestra and lynceus instead. [ 2 ], later killed Danaus to for... Some history is putty in the late first and early second century these. Because others believed they had been denounced as Christians by their jealous husbands putty in the passage, at... Beginning: a disaster followed Jesus the Healer central Greece ) force some of these writers supposedly. Pay for all our sins so that we humans are prone neither repentance. Saw the phrase `` grace of repentance '' in the last chapter are either two unknown women or the was. Capital ) punishment in the last chapter done a clean job in your posting on Jesus Healer! Parents, CHILD, FRIEND ) hated Antiope and treated her cruelly, until Antiope, the. To Acts, was in trouble not for being a disturber of the ]...